Sunday, February 26, 2006

Getting Down From My Carriage...

I’m taking a hint from Lao Tzu and breakin’ down this ancient wisdom with a little modern remix and personal fusion.

What? What?!

At the age of twenty-two, I’ve decided to spend three years in the land of my origin, China, the Middle Kingdom.

For a Chinese American like myself, it is easy to forget where I am from. In America we try so damn hard to fit in and we lose so damn much in the process. Slowly what begins as a charade turns into routine, then the routine becomes natural, and before you know it we’ve got double identities that are blurred so much around the edges we can’t even articulate why it feels so different to be with a bunch of Asians as oppose to a bunch of Whites or Blacks. I believe that of all the ethnic minorities in America, Asian Americans own some of the most confusing struggles with identity around. Think about it. Why do we carry hip hop wannabe attitudes around in dark preppy outfits (East Coast?) or colorful sunny attire (West Coast?)? Why is it easier to make fun of ourselves based on the negative stereotypes in order to fit in then to pridefully claim our true ethnic heritage to the discomfort of others? There’s something in the tension of ‘model minority’ success and ‘perpetual foreigner’ ‘racism that pushes us in every sort of direction except what is traditionally ours.

If yer Asian American and you feelin’ me, holla back. (There it goes again...)

I’ve been thinking hard about this stuff since my senior year at Wheaton, and now that I’m here in the land of my origin there’s a lot more to consider.

You know, I never really had any intention of living in China for any extended period of time. A visit on occasion would have been good enough. My heart and passion, even now, still remains nestled in the US and its own unique circumstances and global influences. Yet somehow during my last year of college, I felt like I needed to be here. It was just a feeling. And if it weren’t for Jerry Redfield III’s own determination and calling to be here, I would never have seriously considered it. He needed help finding a connection and I volunteered. In the process I ended up connecting myself. It is amazing how Father weaves relationships into one another for His purpose.

So here I am in China living, teaching, serving, and on my knees daily for direction as to what to do next. It has been exactly a week since I’ve returned since my winter holiday and everything feels a little bit different. The newness and adjustment is beginning to fade and I find myself beginning to ponder and struggle with things beyond just learning how to teach, getting along with teammates, and so on. My mind is being turned toward other things and this is one of them: the question of identity.

China is a wonderful place for the active soul. The amount to see and do underneath the surface of the everyday is infinite and the potential for growth is overwhelming. I feel that as a Chinese American that potential is doubled.

I mean, haven’t you heard the hype? China is on the rise and the world is beginning to shake! As a Chinese American that means something both exhilarating and frightful.

For all those who’ve spent decades as the model minority and perpetual foreigner, it feels somewhat good to know that your motherland is standing up for itself even if your connection to her is minimal. I’m not saying you have to call it home, but there’s a richness in knowing the history, in knowing your part and your connection. For anyone who still has that connection, there’s a growing resurgence in showing it off. For those who don’t have it, there’s a growing desire to find it. I’m a living example of both.

We’re Chinese and we’re proud of it, but do we really know what that means?

Yet if anything goes wrong between the land we remember as our origin and the land we now call home (specifically in relation to that unmentionable island that many of us also call... err... home... this is thin ice here), we’re the ones who’ll be caught in the dangerous middle. Makes me think of the Japanese Americans of WWII. That’s something to be scared of.

What a time to be part of the Chinese diaspora. Shoot, there’s enough of us outside of China to make up populations of entire countries! But for now I am in China, and being Chinese American in China is a whole other world that no one (not even other Asian Americans or other Chinese diaspora members) can fathom.

What do they see when they look at me, when they hear me talk and watch me act? America in the Chinese mind is already filled to the brim with contradicting concepts of glory and shame. How does it feel to have one of their own be one of them?

To one degree I think they pity me for not knowing where I am from, not understanding the depths of a proud line of tradition. To another degree, I’m admired for all the glitz America has come to represent: the way I move and talk shouts ‘coolness’ just by nature of the American way I was raised.

I’m starting to think Chinese Americans like myself touch a unique part of the raw yet wounded superiority/inferiority complex that the native Chinese have come to be known for. They hate that they love me for my Americanness, but they are proud that I am ethnically Chinese, having risen to the potentials that a Chinese ought to. They can feel comfortable with the uneasy tension that I am Chinese but I am not. They can pick and choose what they like when they feel so and what they don’t depending on the mood. There’s a lot of flexibility and the contradictions are all okay.

After all, the Chinese mind itself is already a terribly mixed up pot of Confucian, Taoist, Buddhist, Neo-marxist, and newer ideas (ahem... to get rich is glorious). It’s easy to be confused. It’s easy to get use to the tension. But that's another chain of thoughts I won't go down now.

And how do I as a Chinese American respond? There is a unique tension here as well. If we felt displaced in America, it’s usually much worse in China. There’s nothing like looking the part but not being anywhere near close. As a result it can be easier to take the American glory treatment and run with it. After all, American culture continues to be cool and sought after while more and more traditional Chinese culture is being put aside. It’d be easy to stand as a living Chinese example of all that modern American influence can do.

You’d be damn cool, but is it worth it to gain the world and lose your soul?

That’s not an exaggeration either. For those Chinese Americans who have come to China to work and play the American way, you’ll lose your Chinese-ness faster than if you were still in America because the Chinese themselves would discard you as a foreigner with a yellow face. If you thought being rejected as an American felt bad, being rejected as a Chinese will feel even worse. You’d isolate yourself amongst everyone except your small American ghetto of friends.

“Yea, I’m American! What!?” But are you really?

For those Chinese Americans who choose to actively engage the culture, regardless of how much Chinese culture you actually have in you, I’ve found the results to be most worthwhile. When a foreigner takes interest in Chinese culture they are usually looked upon with amusement. In addition it builds the Chinese pride up to know others are honoring the culture they so rarely honor themselves these days.

But when a Chinese American seeks out the culture there is a feeling of homecoming, a sense that the prodigal son has returned.

Again, this is not an exaggeration. I have found that there is nothing that connects me more to my students and colleagues than an active engagement in things Chinese, whether I fully understand it or not. When I do this there is something that re-awakens a Chinese person’s engagement with their own culture because I, a Chinese who has everything desirable in a Western sense, wants what is past and not what is now. In an age when Chinese seek to be as modern (aka Western) as they can, an ethnic brother seeking to re-discover the traditions of his past builds a genuine pride. That pride takes the lens of pity the Chinese see me through and turns it into actions of care.

“Yea, I’m Chinese. Can you teach me what that means again?”

It’s a very interesting difference.

In America I can be as ‘American’ as I want, but because of my Asian face I am never fully accepted for one reason or another.

That’s a horrible feeling.

Here in China I will probably never learn to dress, talk, or move like a native Chinese. I will never understand fully the Chinese worldview. But amazingly... if in humility I put forth real honest effort to learn... In China, I am still welcomed as Chinese.

That’s a good feeling.

The tension of being Chinese and American will always be there but tension is good. Tension moves things forward and creates. It’s what we do with tension that makes all the difference. Never let tension break you. Never just sit in it and whine. But let it move you forward.

"Tension is to be loved when it is but a passing note to a beautiful, beautiful chord." -Sixpence None The Richer

In the end we, Chinese Americans, hold a special place in the story of the Chinese people. We are the ones who escaped China at its worst but in the process have forgotten China at its best. We are ones who struggle with an especially unique facet of inferiority and superiority that even native Chinese can’t touch. We are the ones who will never fully understand but know more than either group ever will. We are the ones who bridge a gap between two of the most powerful nations of the modern age. That’s both a privilege and a curse.

There’s a lot to un-package here, I’ve clearly only scratched the surface. I don’t want to be a monologue either. If you’ve read this and you’ve got your own unique experiences of being Chinese American in China, lemme hear it. I’m just starting to think about this.

I trust that my Father in His sovereignty put me here for many reasons. I believe one of them is to faithfully wrestle with these questions of a globalized identity. But I mustn’t get ahead of myself, I’ve only been here half a year. There are two and a half more to come. I’ll potentially be a very different person then. Will I be more Chinese? I don’t know. I don’t think that’s important. What’s important is if I’ll be more ‘me.’ For now, just let me live faithfully day to day and enjoy the blessing of getting in touch with my roots and connecting with a new part of the world. This is enough for now.

Yea, Lao Tzu. I’m glad I got down from my carriage.